Browse topics

Curriculum

Explore all 1,590 open curriculum concepts.

Advanced filters

Science Scientific Inquiry Ages 8–12

Comparing Possible Solutions

Generate and compare multiple possible solutions to a problem based on how well each is likely to meet the criteria and constraints

Teach
Share

Where this fits

Nearby topics in the curriculum — prerequisites on one side, what opens next on the other.

1 before · 3 after

Loading map…
List nearby topics
Preview the lesson

Lesson

Set out your lesson

“Several ideas may meet a need. Compare each with the same criteria and constraints. Likely means a prediction, not a measured result. If evidence is missing, uncertain is a better rating than an invented pass. Safety: Paper planning only; no actual cutting or fastening tools. Stop: End with one selected proposal. Do not silently turn predicted ratings into test results.”

Bring to the table

  • Paper, pencil and ruler
  • One reused sheet available to inspect; no construction required
Extra for the adult

Worked example. Illustrative comparison: a channel has raised sides and a planned 12 cm by 8 cm base; a sleeve may need fastening to stay closed. Answer: the channel is promising because its sides may block rolling and its planned footprint fits. Its actual performance remains untested.

Optional challenge. Revise an idea that fails a constraint while preserving its useful feature.

What to notice. Keep all sketches and the comparison table. Note supplied seed use and adult suggestions.

Ways to teach

Ways to teach

Pick a way to teach this topic. Come back here afterward to record progress.

Gakuva

Several ideas may meet a need. Compare each with the same criteria and constraints. Likely means a prediction, not a measured result. If evidence is missing, uncertain is a better rating than an invented pass. Safety: Paper planning only; no actual cutting or fastening tools. Stop: End with one selected proposal. Do not silently turn predicted ratings into test results.

Teach

US EPA

Students

Open (new tab)
About this link

Students supports Comparing Possible Solutions. An adult previews and guides; this is a learning page, not a scored quiz.

US EPA. “Students.” External page; Gakuva does not copy, host, embed, or redistribute materials.

Unknown — link only

Family records and proof options

Keep a record of your learning

Save photos, notes, and attendance. Export a proof packet for compliance or portfolio reviews.

Check understanding and curriculum record

Check understanding

One short check after the Activity — not a second lesson.

“Can your child brainstorm several different solutions to a design challenge and then compare them to decide which one best meets the requirements?”
Full curriculum checks
  • Generate at least three possible solutions to a defined design problem
  • Compare solutions against the specified criteria and constraints
  • Select the most promising solution with reasoning for the choice
Curriculum record
Type
Procedural
Subject
Science
Domain
Scientific Inquiry
Age range
Ages 8–12

Standards

acara-v9:AC9HS3S06acara-v9:AC9HS4S06acara-v9:AC9HS5S06acara-v9:AC9HS6S06acara-v9:AC9TDE4P02acara-v9:AC9TDE4P04acara-v9:AC9TDE6P02acara-v9:AC9TDE6P04acara-v9:AC9TDI4P03acara-v9:AC9TDI4P05acara-v9:AC9TDI6P04acara-v9:AC9TDI6P06ngss-k5:3-5-ETS1-2