Comparing Possible Solutions
Generate and compare multiple possible solutions to a problem based on how well each is likely to meet the criteria and constraints
Share
Where this fits
Nearby topics in the curriculum — prerequisites on one side, what opens next on the other.
1 before · 3 after
List nearby topics
This concept
Preview the lesson
Lesson
Set out your lesson
“Several ideas may meet a need. Compare each with the same criteria and constraints. Likely means a prediction, not a measured result. If evidence is missing, uncertain is a better rating than an invented pass. Safety: Paper planning only; no actual cutting or fastening tools. Stop: End with one selected proposal. Do not silently turn predicted ratings into test results.”
Bring to the table
- Paper, pencil and ruler
- One reused sheet available to inspect; no construction required
Extra for the adult
Worked example. Illustrative comparison: a channel has raised sides and a planned 12 cm by 8 cm base; a sleeve may need fastening to stay closed. Answer: the channel is promising because its sides may block rolling and its planned footprint fits. Its actual performance remains untested.
Optional challenge. Revise an idea that fails a constraint while preserving its useful feature.
What to notice. Keep all sketches and the comparison table. Note supplied seed use and adult suggestions.
Ways to teach
Ways to teach
Pick a way to teach this topic. Come back here afterward to record progress.
Gakuva
Several ideas may meet a need. Compare each with the same criteria and constraints. Likely means a prediction, not a measured result. If evidence is missing, uncertain is a better rating than an invented pass. Safety: Paper planning only; no actual cutting or fastening tools. Stop: End with one selected proposal. Do not silently turn predicted ratings into test results.
US EPA
Students
About this link
Students supports Comparing Possible Solutions. An adult previews and guides; this is a learning page, not a scored quiz.
US EPA. “Students.” External page; Gakuva does not copy, host, embed, or redistribute materials.
Unknown — link only
Family records and proof options
Keep a record of your learning
Save photos, notes, and attendance. Export a proof packet for compliance or portfolio reviews.
Check understanding and curriculum record
Check understanding
One short check after the Activity — not a second lesson.
“Can your child brainstorm several different solutions to a design challenge and then compare them to decide which one best meets the requirements?”
Full curriculum checks
- Generate at least three possible solutions to a defined design problem
- Compare solutions against the specified criteria and constraints
- Select the most promising solution with reasoning for the choice
Curriculum record
- Type
- Procedural
- Subject
- Science
- Domain
- Scientific Inquiry
- Age range
- Ages 8–12
Standards